NO FEES OR COSTS UNLESS WE WIN!

Bradley D. Souders, P.A. Call Us Toll Free for free 24/7 Consultations: 1-866-HogLaw1 (1-866-464-5291)

Back to Blog

13 Costly Mistakes: That Can Ruin Your Motorcycle Accident Case In Florida

After a motorcycle accident in Florida, the insurance company starts evaluating your case immediately. What most riders do not realize is that the value of a case can rise or fall based on what happens in the first days and weeks after the crash. Some mistakes can permanently reduce your settlement – even before you fully understand your injuries.

Here are thirteen of the biggest mistakes we see in Florida motorcycle accident cases and how to avoid them.

Quick Answer: What Hurts a Motorcycle Accident Case the Most?

The most common mistakes that reduce motorcycle accident settlements in Florida include:

  1. Admitting Fault
  2. Not Calling Law Enforcement:
  3. Failing to Gather Evidence:
  4. Talking to the Insurance Company
  5. Delaying Medical Treatment
  6. Failing to provide your Health Insurance to your Medical Providers or their Billing departments
  7. Failing to Identify All Insurance Coverage
  8. Not Understanding All Applicable Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist ("UM") coverage
  9. Posting on Social Media
  10. Accepting The First Settlement Offer
  11. Waiting Too Long to Take Action
  12. Accepting A Quick Settlement
  13. Not Following Advice or Recommendations of Your Attorney

Most of these mistakes can permanently reduce the value of a case.

Mistake #0 - Waiting Until You Need a Lawyer

The biggest misconception riders have is believing they only need a lawyer after the insurance company causes problems. By then, evidence may already be lost, witnesses may disappear, and recorded statements may already exist.

Mistake #1 – Admitting Fault:

After an accident, a simple apology can be misunderstood.

Avoid statements such as:

  • "I didn’t see you"
  • "I was going to fast"
  • "It was my fault"

What to do instead, only provide statements to the police to allow them to complete their accident investigation so they may draw related official reports.

Mistake #2 – Not Calling Law Enforcement/Not Obtaining A Crash Report:

Some biker may feel they are okay, the damages seem minor or they can handle the matters on their own. By not having a police report, documenting the crash, the biker is doing himself or herself a big mistake!

By calling 911 and requesting first responders to arrive at the scene, you ultimately receive a copy of the Florida Drivers Exchange of Information, also to receive the Florida Traffic Crash Report – Long form (within 10 days afterwards).

The Florida Traffic Crash Report – Long Form – (an official record) provides details of:

  • The date, time, and place of crash
  • The location of the accident
  • The weather conditions
  • Whether there were any contributing circumstances (i.e., construction defects)(road defects)(Failure to Follow FDOT rules)(Maintenance of Traffic)(MOT rules)
  • The vehicles including the year, make, model, license plate, vin number, estimated damage, insurance company, ownership, direction of travel, estimated speed, area of initial impact, maneuvers, and applicable traffic control devices.
  • Improper Equipment of the other vehicle.
  • The drivers including official identification, date of birth, telephone number, address, driver's license number, injury severity rating, safety equipment in use, actions at time of crash, transport by EMS, medical facility destination(s)
  • The driver’s distractions or possible impairment, with reference to other official criminal reports.
  • Passengers of vehicles
  • Other vehicles and related drivers who may have also been at fault
  • Witnesses of the crash
  • Violations issued to at fault driver
  • Investigative Agency Report Number
  • State Crash Report Number
  • Narrative description of the crash
  • Statements of the drivers and witnesses involved
  • Reporting Officer & whether pictures were taken by the officer
  • Diagram of the crash.

Absent having a police investigation and related report, proving how the accident happened and whose fault it was becomes more difficult.

Mistake #3 – Failing to Gather Evidence:

If you are able to do so, take pictures of:

  • Your motorcycle – best to be taken at the scene. Otherwise, at the tow yard.
  • All vehicles involved – best taken at the scene.
  • Road conditions
  • Skid marks
  • Traffic Signs or Traffic Control Devices applicable to your lane of travel and applicable to the other driver.
  • Visible injuries – from top to bottom, head to toe. As injuries change in days, weeks and later, continue to take updated photographs.
  • Witnesses – their full names and contact information, address, email, and telephone number(s).
  • Driver Information.
  • Insurance information.
  • Canvass the crash scene by visiting nearby businesses to learn of additional witnesses or video footage that may have captured the crash itself.

If you are not able to do so, you could ask first responders to take pictures for you. Whether done by yourself, bystanders, paramedics, or witnesses, taking photographs of the vehicles, the crash scene, and your injuries helps your case.

Try to also obtain all witnesses to the accident, as police reports sometimes neglect to list witnesses on the crash report.

By hiring an attorney quickly, the attorney or his or her private investigator can take crash scene photographs, property damage photographs, witness statements and other important details.

Evidence collected soon after the accident can be critical to proving who was at fault, and can also be critical to proving up your damages.

Mistake #4 – Talking to the Insurance Company

After an accident, the insurance company may call quickly and sound helpful. Their goal is to protect the insurance company's monetary interests.

They are calling to:

  • Get a recorded statement
  • Lock you into early details
  • Minimize your claim before you know the full extent of your injuries

Even simple statements like "I feel okay" can be used later to reduce your case value.

What to do instead: Limit communication and avoid recorded statements until you understand your injuries and your legal position.

We have seen riders lose substantial value because they gave recorded statements before fully understanding their injuries. In one case, a rider initially told the insurer he was "fine" before learning the rider had an MRI revealing cervical disc injuries and requiring injections.

Mistake #5 – Delaying Medical Treatment

Waiting days or weeks to seek treatment can seriously damage your case.

Florida Insurance companies and defense attorneys often argue:

  • Your injuries were not serious
  • Something else caused them
  • You made your condition worse

Even if you are genuinely trying to "tough it out" it can be used against you.

What to do instead: Get evaluated as soon as possible - even if the symptoms seem minor.

Mistake #6 – Failing to provide your Health Insurance to your Medical Providers or their Billing Departments

Whether it is Fire Rescue, Ambulance Transportation, Emergency Room, Hospital, Radiology, or any other providers, once they hear you were involved in an automobile accident, many times they will ask you for your automobile insurance – as they are used to seeing persons involved in car accidents and they follow the usual procedure of billing your automobile insurance first.

Such folks may not understand the difference between a motorcycle accident and a car accident. If you were in a car, your own automobile insurance, through the Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage is first in line to pay your medical bills. As a motorcyclist, by law, such "PIP" coverage simply does not apply to motorcyclists. Thus, if your healthcare providers mistakenly bill your auto insurance under your PIP coverage, such bills are only going to be denied by your automobile insurance company. For every motorcyclist, it is important to advise the billing departments of each provider seen or to be seen that you are a motorcyclist, PIP coverage does not apply, and you should provide them your health insurance information to bill your health insurance company. Otherwise, you might find yourself later with unpaid bills, also affecting your good credit.

Mistake #7 – Failing to Identify All Insurance Coverage

This is one of the biggest - and most expensive - mistakes. Many riders assume: "The driver has no insurance, so there's no case." That is often wrong.

In serious motorcycle insurance cases, findings of additional insurance coverage can dramatically change the value of a claim. Many cases involve more than one potential policy,

There may be:

  • At fault driver's injury liability insurance.
  • At fault vehicle's owner liability insurance.
  • Excess liability insurance.
  • Employer liability insurance (if the driver is working)
  • Employer liability/excess liability coverage.
  • Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM) coverage
  • Additional hidden policies – such as finding you have UM coverage in your automobile insurance policy or of any resident relatives who have automobiles of their own with "stacking" coverage.

Most firms:

  • Barely understand UM stacking,
  • Do not discuss resident relative coverage
  • Do not discuss excess/employer policies.

This is why we say:

In serious motorcycle accident cases, identifying additional insurance coverage can completely change the value of a case. For more on this, see: Uninsured Motorcycle Accident in Florida

Mistake #8 – Not Understanding All Applicable Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist ("UM") Coverage:

Florida motorcycle cases are different.

Unlike car accidents:

  • PIP coverage usually does not apply to motorcycles
  • Your recovery often depends on UM coverage

Many riders do not even know:

  • Whether they have UM coverage
  • How much coverage they have
  • How it applies to their accident

This is critical. Without understanding your coverage, you may be undervaluing your case.

Mistake #9 – Posting on Social Media

This one surprises a lot of people.

Insurance companies and defense attorneys routinely monitor:

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube
  • Travel posts
  • Gym photos
  • Activity updates

Even innocent postings may suggest: "You're not as injured as you claim."

Best practice: Avoid posting about your accident, injuries or activities while your case is ongoing.

Mistake #10 – Accepting the First Settlement Offer

Early offers are always low offers.

Why? Because

  • You do not yet know the full extent of your injuries
  • Future treatment costs are not clear
  • The insurance company is testing whether you will settle quickly

Once you accept:

Your case is over. You cannot go back for more.

Mistake #11 – Waiting Too Long to Take Action

Florida has a two-year statute of limitations for personal injury claims. But waiting does not just risk missing the deadline.

It also:

  • makes evidence harder to obtain
  • weakens witness testimony
  • reduces leverage in negotiations

Learn more: Florida Motorcycle Accident Deadline (2-year rule)

Accepting A Quick Insurance Settlement

Settlement offers often arrive before accident victims know the full extent of their injuries.

Upon acceptance of a settlement offer and signing a general release agreement, in most cases, you may not seek any additional compensation afterwards.

Prior to accepting any offer, it is important that you understand your:

All parties who may be legally responsible for your damages, including the at fault driver, the owner of the vehicle, any employer of the at fault driver, all applicable insurance agreements and all applicable uninsured/underinsured motorist insurance agreeements to adequately cover your:

  • Past medical expenses
  • Future medical expenses
  • Past lost wages
  • Future lost wages or how the injuries impact your ability to earn future income
  • Permanent injuries, symptoms, limitations and restrictions
  • Past and future pain and suffering
  • All other special damages (past and future)(economic & non-economic) caused by the accident

Mistake #13 – Not Following the Advice or Recommendations of Your Attorney

By not following the recommendations of your attorney:

  • The value of your case may decrease.

Common recommendations are:

  • Obtain prompt professional medical treatment
  • Follow professional recommendations from your medical providers regarding testing, treatment and possible referrals to specialists.
  • Attend all scheduled doctor appointments – do not cancel or miss appointments.
  • Follow all treatment plans. By doing so, you seek and obtain obtain your best possible medical and financial recovery.
  • Preserve evidence
  • Avoid social media activity
  • Avoid contact with insurance companies, do not give any statements without your attorney present ansd let your attorney handle everyting for you.
  • Keep an Accident Folder To Stay Organized (Paper folder & Email Folder).

After you have reached your maximum medical improvement, provide a comprehensive list of each and every medical provider you have seen, providing copies of all medical bills received, also providing copies of all other correspondence received, including from your health insurance carrier or their reimbursement agent, or anyone else who have given you notice of any lien rights.

When a client ignores recommendations of his or her attorney and medical professionals, the insurance company is likely to argue:

  • The injuries were not serious
  • The medical records show large gaps in treatment
  • The injuries healed quickly
  • The injuries were caused by something else
  • The client failed to mitigate his or her damages, making the condition worse by not obtaining proper care.

The Practical Reality:

As a surgeon once told me, to obtain your best medical recovery – think of a three-legged bar stool. One leg is your physician – having a great physician is critically important. The second leg is the physical thereapy department – following up with scheduled formal physical therapy appointments is important. The third leg is you – the patient. You must follow all doctor recommendations, attend all formal physical therapy sessions, perform all home exercies prescribed, also following all restrictions or limited activities for a time period to allow for proper healing and best recovery.

Like the above, the most succcess motorycle injury cases with the best financial recoveries involve three participants.

  • A client who follows medical and legal advice.
  • Treating providers who properly document and treat injuries.
  • An attorney who can present a consistent, well supported damages claim.

When one of the above elements breaks down, especially client compliance, the case has less value, even if fault for the crash is not disputed.

FAQ: Motorcycle Accident Mistakes in Florida

Why Motorcycle Cases Are Different?

Motorcycle accident cases are often more complex than standard car accident claims because:

  • PIP typically does not apply
  • Severe injuries are more common
  • Insurance coverage investigations matter more
  • Bias against riders an affect settlement negotiations

How Long After a Motorcycle Accident Should I See a Doctor?

As soon as possible. Insurance companies look at initial medical records comparing dates following the accident. If they see you waited weeks before seeking medical care, they will think you suffered minor injuries. Instead, you should present to either an urgent care or emergency room, providing all of your complaints or symptoms, to allow medical professionals to diagnose all injuries, discuss treatment options and recommendations. This helps medically and legally, as your damages are documented in a proper and professional manner.

Can social media hurt a motorcycle accident claim?

Yes, insurance companies and defense attorneys watch social media, and routinely monitor:

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • YouTube

Such information almost works as a modern day surveillance – allowing the defense to obtain more information about your lifestyle, activities and any comments you posted about the crash or your injuries.

Should I talk to the other driver's insurance company?

Before speaking with the other driver's insurance company, it is usually best to understand your legal position and the nature of your injuries.

What if I was partially at fault?

Admit nothing. Often times after an accident, your adrenaline is going, there might have been other things happening you did not see or have the ability to know about. Save this question for your legal counsel, be truthful with your attorney, share your concern and follow your attorney's instructions.

What if I was not wearing a helmet?

It depends: : If you suffered injuries to other parts of your body, and did not suffer a head injury, then it does not matter. Insurance companies cannot blame a back injury or a leg injury on your failure to wear a helmet – as helmets do not offer protection to other parts of your body. On the other hand, if you suffered injuries to your head, then yes, the insurance company is likely to argue your failure to wear a helmet caused the head injuries which you complain of – and this latter scenario could affect the value of your claim.

Does Florida PIP cover motorcycles?

Answer: No automobile insurance policies with their Personal Injury Protection ("PIP") coverage does not apply to a motorcyclists. Such insurance coverage does not follow you onto the bike and will not pay any benefits for medical bills or lost wages.

What Should a Motorcyclist Do When Hospitals, Doctors or other Providers ask for your PIP insurance information?

If a motorcyclist presents to an urgent care facility, emergency room, hospital or otherwise, the motorcyclist should advise the billing department or registration department he or she was on a motorcycle, PIP does not apply and the medical providers should submit their billing to your health insurance coverage.

How long do motorcycle accident settlements take?

It depends: :If there are no questions as to fault and if we have minor to moderate injuries with decent insurance coverage, the case can resolve soon. If there are no questions as to fault and we have catastrophic injuries with high insurance coverage, such cases take longer to build and develop to measure all damages, and these type of cases take longer, also to meet the objectives of obtaining best medical care for best recovery, and best settlement or recovery, to obtaining the absolute best financial recovery.

Can mistakes really reduce my settlement?

Yes. Insurance companies look for anything they can use to lower value- including statements, delays in treatment, and gaps in evidence.

What if I already made one of these mistakes?

Not all mistakes are fatal - but they can complicate your case. The sooner you address them, the better.

Do most motorcycle accident cases settle?

Yes, most cases settle - but the value of that settlement depends heavily on how the case is managed early on.

What if the driver had no insurance?

You may still have options through UM coverage or other sources of liability. Many riders underestimate this.

Talk to a Motorcycle Accident Attorney Before It is Too Late.

Most of these mistakes happen in the first few days after next. And once they happen, they are often permanent.

If you were injured in a motorcycle accident in Florida, we can help you:

  • identify all available insurance coverage
  • avoid common mistakes that reduce value
  • evaluate what your case is actually worth

What Should You Do After a Motorcycle Accident in Florida?

  • Get medical attention immediately
  • Preserve photographs and evidence
  • Avoid recorded statements
  • Review applicable insurance coverage
  • Avoid discussing the case online
  • Speak with an attorney before accepting a settlement
  • Speak with an attorney early who knows the rules of the road – the various avenues to obtaining the best financial recovery.

Insurance Bias Against Motorcyclists

Unfortunately, insurance companies sometimes attempt to portray motorcyclists as:

  • Reckless
  • Speeding
  • Inherently dangerous
  • Or partially at fault.

That is one reason motorcycle accident cases require aggressive early investigation and coverage analysis.

What To Do Immediately after a Motorcycle Accident?

This is one reason early evidence collection and proper case development matter so much in motorcycle claims. Thus, we encourage all visitors to read our "Accident Checklist" to know the what and not to do within the first seven days after an accident.

Injured in a Motorcycle Accident? Speak With a Lifetime Biker–Attorney Today

If you're looking for a Florida motorcycle accident lawyer who actually rides, you're in the right place.

  • 35+ years of trial experience
  • Lifetime biker who understands real riding conditions
  • No fees or costs unless we win
  • Free consultation
  • Help with both medical bills and property damage
  • Personal representation — no case managers

About the Author — Brad Souders, Florida Motorcycle Accident Attorney

Brad Souders is a lifetime biker and veteran trial lawyer with more than 35 years of experience representing injured riders throughout Florida. He combines real riding experience with extensive legal knowledge to help Florida motorcycle accident victims recover full compensation. Main office in Tampa – Representing Bikers And Their Families Throughout Florida.

Brad offers free consultations and flexible appointments, including evenings, weekends, home visits, hospital visits, or virtual meetings. Call Now: 813-220-7767 or 866-464-5291

Call The Motorcycle Attorney That Actually Rides!